A VPN moves your trust from the café to a company. What it sees, the three meanings of "no logs", how free VPNs make money, and why a business VPN differs.
- Date
- Reading
- 7 min read
- Written by
- Nick Li
- Tags
- #Risk#Engineering
In part one we followed a web request through a café's Wi-Fi and showed that a VPN doesn't remove the party who can see where you go; it replaces the café and your internet provider with the VPN company. This article is about that company: what it can see, what "no logs" really means, why free VPNs are rarely free, and the questions to ask before you pay. Part three, next, is for people who want to run their VPN account on a router or with their own software.
The VPN company is your new internet provider
Every connection you make with the VPN on passes through the company's server, which has to open the outer envelope to forward your traffic. That gives it a view of the same things the café used to see:
What the VPN server can see on every connection you make through it
your account → which customer this is (email, payment)
your real address → the cafe's / your home's public IP
when → connect and disconnect times
how much → bytes in, bytes out
where to → the site name (DNS, SNI) and address of every site
what inside → nothing, as long as the site uses HTTPS
Two of those lines are new compared with the café. The company knows who you are, because you have an account and paid somehow, and it sees all of your traffic, from every network you use, not just one café's. A VPN provider therefore sits in a stronger position than any single Wi-Fi owner, which is why the choice of provider matters more than the choice of protocol or server location.
What it still can't do is read the contents of HTTPS sites, your banking included. That padlock is between your browser and the site, and the VPN server forwards it unopened.
"No logs": three different promises
Almost every provider says it keeps no logs. The phrase hides three separate things:
"No logs" can mean very different things
Connection logs who connected, when, from where, how much ← most keep some, briefly
Activity logs which sites, which addresses ← the ones that matter
Billing records name, email, payment ← always kept somewhere
Ask: which of the three, kept for how long, and who checked?
Connection logs are the least sensitive and the most common: timestamps, your real address, data volume, often kept for a few days to catch abuse or to enforce a device limit. Activity logs, the list of sites you visited, are the ones a privacy-minded provider must not keep, and the ones that make a VPN worthless if it does. Billing records always exist unless you pay in a way that doesn't name you.
You can't verify a logging promise yourself, so look for someone who has. Several larger providers now commission independent audits of their servers and policies and publish the reports; some have had their claims tested in court or during a police seizure, where servers turned out to hold nothing useful. A provider that offers only a slogan is asking you to trust it blind. The EFF's guide to choosing a VPN is a good, vendor-neutral reference for what to look for.
Where the company is based matters too. Its country decides which authorities can order it to hand over data or start logging, and whether it must tell you. There is no perfect answer, but a provider should state its jurisdiction plainly rather than leave you guessing.
Why free VPNs are rarely free
Running VPN servers costs real money: bandwidth, hardware, people. A free service pays for that somehow, and the usual ways are the ones you'd least want:
-
Selling your browsing data. The activity log that a paid provider promises not to keep is exactly what a free one can sell to advertisers and data brokers.
-
Injecting ads or tracking into the pages you load, which also means the app sits in a position to tamper with them.
-
Using your connection as an exit point for other customers, so strangers' traffic leaves from your address.
-
The upsell. The honest version: a limited free tier that exists to sell the paid one. Fine, as long as the limits are speed and data, not privacy.
There are reputable free tiers from paid providers. There are also apps with millions of downloads whose only product is you. The difference is usually visible in the privacy policy and in whether a paid plan exists at all. A free VPN with no paid version has to be paid for by someone, and it isn't the provider.
What a VPN still doesn't protect you from
-
Phishing and malware. A fake login page looks the same through a tunnel, and malware on your laptop sends its data through the tunnel like everything else.
-
Accounts you're logged in to. Google, Facebook and your bank know it's you regardless of your address.
-
Leaks around the tunnel. If the VPN drops for a second and the app doesn't block traffic in the meantime, your real address shows. The feature that prevents this is called a kill switch; good apps have it on by default. DNS lookups and IPv6 traffic can also slip outside a badly made tunnel.
-
Weak logins. Most account break-ins come from reused passwords and phishing, not from café Wi-Fi. A VPN does nothing there; passkeys and two-factor login do.
The VPN's job is getting smaller
Two improvements to the web itself are closing the gaps that a VPN used to cover. Encrypted DNS (DNS over HTTPS) hides the lookup of a site's name, and a newer part of HTTPS called Encrypted Client Hello hides the site name in the handshake too. Neither is everywhere yet, but as they spread, the reasons to use a consumer VPN narrow to two: hiding your location from the sites you visit, and reaching a private network. On a café Wi-Fi today, the VPN still earns its keep; in a few years, less so.
A VPN for your business is a different product
The apps advertised on YouTube are consumer VPNs: they take all of your traffic to the internet through someone else's server. What most small companies actually need is the older kind: a private tunnel from staff laptops to your own office or cloud, so the accounting system, the NAS or the admin pages are never exposed to the internet at all. That setup, often built with WireGuard, sends only office traffic through the tunnel and leaves YouTube alone. It's cheaper, faster and more private than routing everyone through a consumer service, and it's what part three covers.
Questions to ask before you pay
-
Which logs do you keep, for how long? Connection, activity, billing: get an answer for each.
-
Who has audited that, and when? Ask for the report, not the badge.
-
Where is the company based, and what happens when a court asks for data?
-
Is there a kill switch, and is it on by default? Also: does the app send DNS through the tunnel?
-
Which protocols? WireGuard or OpenVPN are the ones to expect. A provider with only its own secret protocol should explain why.
-
How do you make money? For a free service, this is the only question that matters.
A note for Hong Kong readers: using a VPN is legal here. This series is about privacy on shared networks and reaching your own systems safely.
A VPN moves your trust from the café to a company. Choose the company as carefully as you'd choose a bank.
If you'd like help setting up a private tunnel from your team's laptops to your own office or cloud, let's talk.
