The first decision when setting up a NAS is RAID. Mirrors and parity in pictures, real space with 4 TB drives, why SHR, and why RAID is not a backup.
- Date
- Reading
- 5 min read
- Written by
- Nick Li
- Tags
- #Engineering#Risk
Buying a NAS is the easy part. The first real decision comes on day one, when the setup wizard asks how to combine the drives: RAID 1, RAID 5, SHR, something else. Pick wrong and you either waste space or lose everything when one drive dies. This is the first of a six-part series on setting up a NAS for a small office or home, written around Synology because that's what most Hong Kong businesses we meet use. The ideas apply to QNAP, UGREEN and others too.
What RAID does, in one sentence
RAID lets several drives work as one, so that when one drive breaks, your files are still there. It does that in one of two ways: keeping exact copies (mirroring), or storing extra recovery information called parity.
RAID 1 (2 drives): every file written twice
Drive 1 [ A ][ B ][ C ]
Drive 2 [ A ][ B ][ C ] ← an exact copy
One drive dies → the other has everything. Usable space = one drive.
RAID 5 (4 drives): data spread across drives, plus one drive's worth of "parity"
Drive 1 [ A1 ][ B1 ][ C1 ][ P ]
Drive 2 [ A2 ][ B2 ][ P ][ D1 ]
Drive 3 [ A3 ][ P ][ C2 ][ D2 ]
Drive 4 [ P ][ B3 ][ C3 ][ D3 ] P = parity: enough to rebuild any ONE missing piece
One drive dies → its contents are recalculated from the other three.
Two drives die → everything is lost. RAID 6 keeps two parities, so it survives two.
The options side by side
| Setup | Drives (min) | Survives | Usable space, 4 TB drives | Good for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| RAID 0 | 2 | no failure | 2 drives → 8 TB | nothing important, ever |
| RAID 1 | 2 | 1 drive | 2 drives → 4 TB | 2-bay NAS |
| RAID 5 | 3 | 1 drive | 4 drives → 12 TB · 5 → 16 TB | most 4- and 5-bay offices |
| RAID 6 | 4 | 2 drives | 4 drives → 8 TB · 5 → 12 TB | large drives, data you can't lose |
| RAID 10 | 4 (even) | 1 for sure, 2 if lucky | 4 drives → 8 TB | databases, virtual machines, speed |
| SHR-1 | 2 | 1 drive | like RAID 1 / RAID 5, more with mixed sizes | most Synology users |
| SHR-2 | 4 | 2 drives | like RAID 6, more with mixed sizes | Synology, large drives |
Synology's free RAID calculator shows the exact space for any mix of drives.
SHR: Synology's own option, and usually the right one
Synology Hybrid RAID (SHR) behaves like the classic types: SHR-1 survives one failed drive (like RAID 1 or 5) and SHR-2 survives two (like RAID 6). The difference shows when drives have different sizes. Classic RAID treats every drive as if it were the smallest one; SHR uses the extra space.
An example: two 4 TB drives and two 8 TB drives. RAID 5 gives you 12 TB, because it counts all four as 4 TB. SHR-1 gives you 16 TB from the same drives. It also lets you grow later by swapping in bigger drives one at a time, which suits a small office that upgrades as it goes.
Two caveats. SHR is a Synology feature, so another brand's NAS can't read the drives. And some of Synology's business lines, such as the XS and FS series, don't offer it; on the desktop models most small offices buy, it's the default.
Which one for your office
-
2-bay NAS: SHR-1 (it's the same as RAID 1 here). The only sensible choice.
-
4- or 5-bay NAS, drives up to about 8 TB: SHR-1 or RAID 5. You lose one drive's worth of space and can survive one failure.
-
4 bays or more with large drives (12 TB and up), or data you truly can't afford to lose: SHR-2 or RAID 6. You give up a second drive's worth of space, for a good reason explained below.
-
Databases, virtual machines or video editing straight from the NAS: RAID 10, which is faster at the cost of half the space.
-
Never RAID 0 or JBOD for business files. One dead drive and everything is gone.
Why big drives push you towards SHR-2
When a drive fails, the NAS rebuilds its contents onto the replacement by reading every other drive from start to finish. With today's large drives that takes many hours, sometimes days, and the remaining drives work hard the whole time. They're usually the same age and from the same batch as the one that just died. If a second drive fails or hits an unreadable spot during that window, RAID 5 and SHR-1 have nothing left to rebuild from. SHR-2 and RAID 6 still have one spare level of protection, which is why we recommend them once drives get large.
Two habits help whatever you choose: keep one spare drive on the shelf, so the rebuild starts the day a drive fails rather than after an order arrives; and, if you can, buy drives from two different shops or batches.
RAID is not a backup
This is the line we'd most like readers to remember. RAID protects you from one thing: a drive wearing out. It does nothing against a file someone deleted, a folder overwritten by mistake, ransomware encrypting the NAS, a burst pipe, a fire or a theft. In all of those, every drive in the RAID holds the same damaged data. Our Synology ransomware article shows how quickly that happens; backups and snapshots, covered later in this series, are what get you out of it.
Coming next
Part 2 takes a new NAS from the box to a working office cloud: the first setup, shared folders for each department, user accounts and permissions, and Synology Drive so staff sync files like Dropbox but on your own hardware. After that: what else a Synology can do, connecting from your phone safely, backing up phone photos, and the security settings every NAS needs.
RAID keeps you working when a drive dies. Only a backup saves you when everything else goes wrong.
If you'd like help choosing a NAS, drives and RAID layout for your office, let's talk.
